diff --git a/pterodactyl/pterodactyl.py b/pterodactyl/pterodactyl.py
index fa34133..4112bce 100644
--- a/pterodactyl/pterodactyl.py
+++ b/pterodactyl/pterodactyl.py
@@ -151,7 +151,8 @@ class Pterodactyl(commands.Cog):
             self.logger.debug("Chat channel not set. Skipping sending chat message to Discord")
 
     async def get_tellraw_string(self, username: str, message: str, color: discord.Color):
-        return await self.config.tellraw_json().replace(".$U", username).replace(".$M", message).replace(".$C", str(color))
+        tellraw = await self.config.tellraw_json()
+        return tellraw.replace(".$U", username).replace(".$M", message).replace(".$C", str(color))
 
     def get_task(self):
         return self.bot.loop.create_task(self.establish_websocket_connection(), name="Pterodactyl Websocket Connection")